Earlier this month the Public Safety Committee held a review of the San Francisco Police Department's Traffic Stop Protocol. This meeting and all other official San Francisco government public meetings can be seen through video on demand provided by the City at sfgov.org.
The SFPD got the short end of the stick at the meeting, but that's nothing new in San Francisco politics.
Police Officers are different?
Sometimes, it is true, individuals within the Department lose their patience, make stupid mistakes, make unethical decisions and simply do the wrong thing. I would be an idiot if I did not recognize that it happens. It is simply not reasonable to assume that in any one profession you will find 100% of the people thinking and doing exactly the same thing all the time.
Police officers may be not different from the general populace in the basic things, like their membership status in the community as parents, husbands, wives, sons and daughters. But beyond that point there is a great difference. Most sworn officers of the San Francisco Police Department are veterans of the United States military. Many of them are decorated heroes. They are some of the sharpest, most accurate, highly-focused, professional, best trained and dedicated police officers anywhere on the planet. Their lives distinguish them.
.
Our police officers really do have a third professional sense and often think the same way and act the same way - maybe not 100% of the time - but a hell of a lot more regularly than you, me or most people we know. They are experienced team players and they have a sense of unit identity that can otherwise only be found in the military.
.
Most officers have families and a number of other commitments to their communities as well. Our officers are gay and straight. They respresent every race and a large number of ethinicities. Many languages are spoken. Many accents are heard. We are proud of the diversity in the Department. The rank and file of the SFPD absolutely and genuinely are San Francicso's Finest.
Police Officers are not our neighbors
I would like to say they are the people who live right in our neighborhood, who go to our churches, who attend school events with other parents, and who push their shopping carts down the same aisles you do, but it is not true.
Many SFPD officers live outside the City because we just don't pay them enough money to afford to bring their families, buy a home and live in San Francisco. Having our officers live in our City is a huge step in folding those officers into the fabric of the community and strenghtening it. But - as long as we continue to underpay our police officers, we will not have the benefit of them and their families living in San Francisco.
Station captains and the Hollywood game show
.
The Department would be able to substantially improve community policing programs if we could slow down the rotation of our station captains. Under current policy rotation occurs every two or three years. How is any captain ever going to be able to develop any new programs when the captains play mandatory musical chairs every few years? For goodness sake, people, this is a police department not a Hollywoood game show. Give them a chance!
Absolute and mandatory non-discrimination policy
A number of speakers at the Public Safety Committee hearing demanded more ethical behavior toward immigrants, non-citizens and temporarily undocumented individuals (aka: illegal aliens).
Everyone absolutely must be treated equally, honestly, fairly and respectfully. IDs must not be seized and kept unless there are violations or registration issues associated with the ID and if the ID is issued by the State of California or the City and County of San Francisco. IDs should otherwise be seized only for the purpose of being used as evidence or in the case of a felony investigation. No SFPD officer should get involved in enforcing federal immigration law.
The men and women of ICE
The men and women of ICE are every bit as professional, responsible and admirable as every other police officer. ICE officers are the good guys. Let's keep this clear.
The political policies of the federal government, particularly during the past eight years, are absolutely at the opposite pole from the political policies here in San Francisco. Bush is gone and Barack Obama is Commander-in-Chief. To the men and women of ICE as well as every other law enforcement agency in the country, to every member of the military in this country and to most veterans in this country a change in Commander-in-Chief has clear and distinct meaning. Police officers leave their party politics in the locker when the star goes on the uniform.
SFPD Officers: Keep you ideas to yourself!
If an officer puts himself or herself into the picture while on duty, then we have a problem. That officer needs to be pulled from the street for awhile. It's not cause for displinary action, but it's clear cause for a little R&R. Sometimes its just a matter of stress and that's more than reasonable considering the intense level of responsibility police officers face every day at work.
Give priority to immigrants and families who fear ICE?
The idea that we should put immigrants and non-green-card individuals into a higher, special status is nuts. Whoever hatched that idea needs to put the pipe down and stop smoking so damn much.
.
United States citizens not only should come first, they must come first and they do come first. The rank and file of the SFPD are not confused about issues like that. Some of my fellow San Franciscans may be confused, but veterans and members of the SFPD have their priorities exactly right: Citizens First.
.
Immigrants and non-green-card people should be treated equally, kindly, morally, respectfully, honestly, politely and professionally. But nobody gets treated with any priority that is higher than the least American citizen. Not in this country.
.
As long as the SFPD stays out of the business of enforcing federal immigration laws there should be no problem.
.
When cops go bad
And to flip the coin, we must not tolerate the behavior of any police officer who disrespects someone because of their immigration status, place of origin, language, ethnicity, gender identity, or the clothes they wear. If I were the Chief and I came across an officer who was letting his/her star go to his or her head, that officer would instantly be off the street and buried behind a plain gray desk in a little ugly room somewhere deep in the bowels of the Hall of Justice with only spiders to talk to.
Police officers should be always mindful that San Francisco policy is supportive of people with immigration violations. It is the policy of the City and County of San Francisco not to enforce immigration law. Police officers absolutely must respect and abide by that policy. Their employers demand it.
More intense oversight of the SFPD
There are some San Francisco government departments and agencies I think we should be watching over, supervising and keeping an eye on. Parking and Traffic comes to mind and so does Muni. Public Works has been known to have their share of loafers on the payroll and I think they deserve some scrutiny as well - but not the rank and file of the SFPD - at least not as intensely as suggested by some of the speakers at the hearing.
Traffic Stop Policy
The issue of traffic stop policy and racial profiling is a very tender subject to just about everybody. My point of view is simple. I want the SFPD to protect me and protect the people I love. That means I have a reason to want to do everything I can to help them catch the bad guys.
I want the City to do absolutely everything it can to respond to the needs of the rank and file and give them all the tools they need to go out there and catch bad guys. As long as the SFPD is operating 100% within the law, I'm opposed to anything that gets in the way of letting officers catch bad guys. I want our officers to obey the law without reservation, obey all departmental policies and go out there and do the best damn job they can and they know how to do it better than I do.
Considerations for traffic stops should be:
- Bystander-citizen safety first
- Officer safety second
- Suspect safety third
I wish more San Francisco citizens would spend more of their time standing behind the rank and file. If they can't stand behind the SFPD, at very least stand aside. But for goodness sake, get the hell out of the way..
..